All orders ship for FREE in the USA!

Best Bagel Sandwiches on the Cape and Islands

Looking for the best bagel sandwiches on the Cape and Islands? We put together a list of some of our favorites! Did we miss any? Leave a comment below!

  • Pie In The Sky (Woods Hole) - located in historic Woods Hole, at the end of the Shining Sea Bike Path and just a 1-minute walk from the Steamship Authority. They feature a delicious assortment of handmade croissants, pies, cookies, popovers, and breads all baked from scratch on the premises. Their hearty, made-to-order sandwiches make the perfect addition to any adventure, from a shoreside picnic to lunch at the office. Stop in to enjoy their courtyard garden and taste the goodness that's been "Baked in the Hole since 1982."

Pie In The Sky

Photo by @juliaeatslikeafuckinggod

  • Bagel Haven (Mashpee) - offering freshly baked bagels daily, delicious breakfast sandwiches, and house-made cream cheese flavors, Bagel Haven is a must-try! They do not have an unlimited supply, therefore it is not uncommon for them to sell out of the most popular flavors later in the day. Come in early to get a made-to-order sandwich, or a sandwich off their menu like the Sliced Lox Sandwich made with cream cheese, sliced lox, tomato, onion, and capers (pictured below)!

Bagel Haven

Photo by @sistersslovefood

  • Mocha Mott's (Oak Bluffs, Vineyard Haven) - opening their flagship location in 1994, they provide organic, fair trade coffee, homemade baked goods, and Cape Cod bagels. The shops are a fun, friendly environment to get your day started in the morning, or visit in the afternoon or evening. Mocha Mott's is a place where locals and visitors mix and meet to enjoy good company, fresh coffee, and delicious sandwiches!

Mocha Mott's

Photo by @foodistagirl

  • Bagel Hound (Wellfleet + Provincetown) - this business began like a real-life Cape Cod fairytale when Claire met Ellery (now owners) working at a restaurant during one long, hot summer. From there, they revamped the local mom & pop (Salty Market), and live happily ever after! Bagel Hound, named in honor of Theo the family basset hound, was born after Ellery discovered his talent and love for baking bagels. Make your own bagel sandwich that is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, loaded with a homemade schmear!

Bagel Hound

Photo by @bagelhoundcapecod

  • The Daily Brew (Cataumet) - serving breakfast and lunch daily, "The Brew" is more than just a coffee house, it is a way of life. They value face-to-face interaction, and getting to know their customers! You can always count on freshly brewed coffee, smoothies, pastries, and delicious breakfast and lunch sandwiches. Stop by The Brew to start your day off, grab a mid-day breakfast sandwich, or before heading to the beach for the day!

The Daily Brew

Photo by @iknowbagels

  • JoMama's New York Bagels & Coffeehouse (Orleans, Chatham, Brewster + Yarmouth) - committed to serving fresh, delicious, and wholesome food in a relaxing atmosphere filled with smiling faces when you visit. Owners Rick and Christy bring an extensive and successful background in the Culinary Arts and Restaurant industries and pride themselves in offering high-quality products and services; they wouldn't want it any other way! Their bagels are boiled in Queens and baked fresh in Orleans. 


Photo by @laurpopeats

  • Cape Cod Bagel (Falmouth) - satisfy your morning cravings at Cape Cod Bagel! Each month they feature a different local artist and their bagels are freshly baked each day. CCB is a local favorite. Make sure to try one of our favorites, the Lox Bagel featuring Cape Cod's favorite bagel with smoked salmon, tomatoes, onions, capers, and your choice of cream cheese (pictured below)!

Cape Cod Bagel

Photo by @two_hungry_chicks

  • The Bagel Dudes (Dennis, Chatham + Falmouth) - a locally family-owned bagel and coffee shop operating locations in Massachusetts and Florida. They strive to be your quintessential neighborhood bagel shop. Offering NY-style bagels that are baked fresh daily in-house, served with homemade schmears and a wide variety of coffee. The Bagel Dudes is a great start to any day!

The Bagel Dudes

Photo by @bagelswithbae

  • The Black Dog Bakery Cafe (Vineyard Haven + Falmouth) - a must for those who love scratch-made goodies. Early risers can start the day with a freshly baked signature BD Woofer egg sandwich, or can be ordered for take-out to bring for a day spent on the beach! Pair your delicious breakfast sandwich with one of their famous freshly baked chocolate chip cookies or pastries. Bring friends and family to relax in the outdoor seating area or the tranquil patio located in front of the vintage 1914 rail car (Vineyard location) or by the Island Queen (Falmouth location)!

The Black Dog Bakery Cafe

Photo by @flamefoodie

  • Coffee Obsession (Falmouth + Woods Hole) - since 1992, they continue to invite people from all over to enjoy a tasty beverage and delicious sandwich in a place as warm and welcoming as your aunt's living room. Featuring a variety of local artists' work, it is a community place where teachers, musicians, scientists, students, locals, and travelers gather to have stimulating conversations. All food is made with love and sincere craftsmanship. The chef provides customers with breakfast and lunch specialties, made per order on a daily basis! Two shops may differ in location, but guests are provided with the same love and dedication. 

Coffee Obsession

Photo by @coffeeobsessioncapecod

  • Provisions Nantucket (Nantucket) - since opening its doors in 1973, Provisions has been a mainstay for breakfast and lunch. Located right on the wharf next to the water, it is a great place to grab your breakfast on the way to the boat or before a beach day! You can enjoy a variety of freshly baked homemade bagels and made-to-order breakfast sandwiches. They offer something yummy for every taste and best of all, it is handmade cooking inspired by your summer on the island!

Provisions Nantucket

Photo by @kcmjusteatin

    Leave a comment

    Please note, comments must be approved before they are published