Best BLTs on the Cape and Islands

April 22, 2025

If you're craving a delicious BLT (Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato) sandwich while visiting Cape Cod and the Islands, here are some of our favorite spots to try. Did we miss any? Leave a comment below!

Among The Flowers Cafe (Edgartown, MV) - located within walking distance to Edgartown Harbor and many of Edgartown's Inns and Shops, Among the Flowers is your place to go for healthy and delicious meals made with fresh and local ingredients. Among the Flowers is family-owned and operated and has been serving locals and tourists for over 45 years. Grab a classic BLT on your choice of sourdough, multigrain, or a sub roll, and take it to go and watch the boats pass in by Edgartown Harbor!

Photo by @amongtheflowerscafe

Something Natural (Nantucket) - for over 50 years, they have taken pride in serving "Good Things To Eat and Drink". A true coastal New England summer must-try is their specialty Lobster BLT, made with fresh lobster and tomatoes straight from Bartlett's Farm!

Photo by @somethingnaturalack

Dennis Public Market (Dennis) - located in the heart of Dennis Village, The Dennis Public Market, locally known as DPM, has had its doors open to the public since 1907. Since 1990 DPM has proudly been owned by the Crosby family. They pride themselves on providing the highest quality foods, including an assortment of different specialty sandwiches. At DPM you, "Can't Go Wrong" ordering the #30, which is their signature BLT with your choice of bread and dressing.

Photo by @yolkin_around

Waterside (Vineyard Haven, MV) - known for having a long-standing reputation for being a community hub, where locals and visitors alike come together for good food, a great atmosphere, and welcoming vibes. They focus on fresh ingredients and innovative recipes made from scratch daily to create killer sandwiches. Waterside believes you can enjoy a BLT at all times of the year. Whether the craving hits for breakfast, lunch, or dinner - nothing beats the classic combo of uncured, nitrate-free bacon, greens, tomato, and mayo on a toasted ciabatta. After all, it's considered "THE BEST" BLT for good reason.

Photo by @waterside_market

Captain Parker's Pub (West Yarmouth) - since 1981, they have been serving hearty New England fare from their lively indoor and outdoor deck. At Captain Parker's Pub, they are passionate about serving their hearty New England fare in a lively atmosphere. Although they are known for their chowder, you can not overlook their delicious Crispy Chicken BLT, a cornflake-breaded chicken breast topped with lettuce, tomato, and bacon served on a brioche roll.

Photo by @captainparkers

Seven Days Restaurant (Dennis) - a go-to destination for delicious American-style cuisine and a welcoming bar. What started as a dream among three friends has turned into a favorite among locals and visitors for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. They prepare all food with the freshest ingredients including the traditional BLT, served with a side of crispy french fries and creamy coleslaw.

Photo by @seven_days593

Provisions (Nantucket) - since opening its doors in 1973, Provisions has been a mainstay for breakfast and lunch. Located right on the wharf next to the water, you can enjoy a variety of made-to-order sandwiches. They offer something yummy for every taste and best of all, it is handmade cooking inspired by your summer on the island! Be sure to grab a delicious BLT and take it to go before heading out on the boat or to the beach for the day!

Photo by @kaitlynclinger

Café Chew (Sandwich) - a healthy and delicious dining experience, with both indoor and outdoor seating that makes you feel right at home. Relax on the patio with a refreshing juice, and be sure to try their traditional BLT sandwich, it's a must!

Photo by @cafe.chew

Keltic Kitchen (West Yarmouth) - the place to get a traditional Irish breakfast. While this is what they are known for, don't overlook their mouthwatering BLT sandwich. For an extra touch, try it with a perfectly fried egg for a delicious twist on a classic!

Photo by @keltickitchen